Of course there are real problems and real dangers. Nonetheless, most Americans are happy with their own lives. This reflects the fact that there are many, many things right with our society. Moreover, we solve problems all the time. We have a strong tradition of improving, which is as active at this moment as it ever has been.
It is a psychological quirk of human beings that we pay more attention to threats than to blessings. This makes us think that a large proportion of our life conditions are dangerous. Yet a calm inventory of each of the people and institutions that we rely on each day would clearly show that most of what we depend on is actually working.
In my judgment, the people who spread fear are a greater danger to the happiness of society than are the people and circumstances they are afraid of.
Friday, October 07, 2011
Wednesday, October 05, 2011
The Close Parallel in the Sociology of the Virtues and of Religion
I was struck by a helpful analogy between two literatures that I have been reading.
Aristotle, in the Nicomachean Ethics, says that the main end of life is happiness. Happiness, he says, is an action of the soul in accordance with virtue. The whole middle of the book is a detailed consideration of the action involved in cultivating each of the main virtues.
And then in the last chapter he throws a curveball. He says that there is a virtue that is different from all these active virtues. It is higher, and ultimately makes those who can achieve it the happiest of all. This is the virtue of contemplation. Contemplation is what the gods do often, and in contemplating we come as close to being like the gods as human beings can.
The sociology of religion finds over and over again that the religion has many good effects for religious people. The main good effects come to those who participate in religious institutions, becoming part of a network who help one another and who spur each other to help others, as well. This leads some people to say that religious institutions are really just social clubs, and the same benefit could be had from all kinds of secular social clubs.
However, in the last chapter, as it were, the sociologists of religion find that there is a kind of religious experience that is different from all this social relationship practice. It is higher, and ultimately makes those who achieve it the most fulfilled of all. This is the practice of contemplating and experiencing God.
Nearly everyone contemplates sometimes. Nearly everyone contemplates God and experiences the transcendent sometimes. However, only what Max Weber calls the virtuosi make a habit of contemplation (like the gods) and make a habit of contemplating God.
Aristotle, in the Nicomachean Ethics, says that the main end of life is happiness. Happiness, he says, is an action of the soul in accordance with virtue. The whole middle of the book is a detailed consideration of the action involved in cultivating each of the main virtues.
And then in the last chapter he throws a curveball. He says that there is a virtue that is different from all these active virtues. It is higher, and ultimately makes those who can achieve it the happiest of all. This is the virtue of contemplation. Contemplation is what the gods do often, and in contemplating we come as close to being like the gods as human beings can.
The sociology of religion finds over and over again that the religion has many good effects for religious people. The main good effects come to those who participate in religious institutions, becoming part of a network who help one another and who spur each other to help others, as well. This leads some people to say that religious institutions are really just social clubs, and the same benefit could be had from all kinds of secular social clubs.
However, in the last chapter, as it were, the sociologists of religion find that there is a kind of religious experience that is different from all this social relationship practice. It is higher, and ultimately makes those who achieve it the most fulfilled of all. This is the practice of contemplating and experiencing God.
Nearly everyone contemplates sometimes. Nearly everyone contemplates God and experiences the transcendent sometimes. However, only what Max Weber calls the virtuosi make a habit of contemplation (like the gods) and make a habit of contemplating God.
Monday, October 03, 2011
Is Marriage for White People? Is a Pretty Good Analysis
The black marriage rate has declined precipitously in the past half century. A gap has opened between black and white marriage rates which was not true two generations ago. Similarly, a gap has opened between the out-marriage rate (that is, marrying outside their race) of black women and black men, which was not true two generations ago.
Banks' main conclusion is that the imbalance in the relationship market is the main culprit. There are many more black women ready for marriage than there are black men. This lets black men, as a group, get the benefits of marriage, including children, without the obligations.
Banks concludes that if black women were more willing to marry out, the power balance would become more even. In the end, more black men and women would marry each other.
Banks' main conclusion is that the imbalance in the relationship market is the main culprit. There are many more black women ready for marriage than there are black men. This lets black men, as a group, get the benefits of marriage, including children, without the obligations.
Banks concludes that if black women were more willing to marry out, the power balance would become more even. In the end, more black men and women would marry each other.
Sunday, October 02, 2011
The Two Parties Agree: Democrats Care More About the Poor, Republicans Care More About the Rich
A YouGov/Economist poll found that most Americans agree that the Democratic Party is more concerned about poor people, and the Republic Party is more concerned about rich people. Democrats and Republicans are about equally likely to see the two parties this way.
There is a kind of balance in this division of labor, with each party holding down their end of the seesaw.
People of both parties and no party agree that millionaires should be taxed more. Even about half of Republicans agree on this point.
There is a kind of balance in this division of labor, with each party holding down their end of the seesaw.
People of both parties and no party agree that millionaires should be taxed more. Even about half of Republicans agree on this point.
Saturday, October 01, 2011
Csikszentmihalyi's Disappointing "Flow"
One of the most cited works in the positive psychology canon is Mihalyi Csikszentmihalyi's Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience. I think the main idea is sound and helpful. But the book itself is surprisingly and unnecessarily negative.
"Flow" is what we feel when we are having what he calls an optimal experience. He describes these as “when a person’s body or mind is stretched to its limits in a voluntary effort to accomplish something difficult and worthwhile.” The flow channel is an optimal path between anxiety and boredom, where your skills and your challenges meet. The result of experiencing flow is that your own consciousness becomes more complex.
Most of Csikszentmihalyi's examples come from avocations - music, art, athletics, crafts. He says that we can experience flow in our jobs as well, though most of his examples are drawn from the white collar professions. It was surprising to me that he did not treat marriage or childrearing as common settings for flow - the social relationships at the core of positive psychology. Instead, the social relationships chapter was mostly about friendship.
Most of positive psychology treats religion as the most reliable setting, outside of family life, for positive relations, for serving others and feeling that your life is a meaningful part of a larger whole.
Csikszentmihalyi, on the other hand, pronounces religion false, and worse. He simply declares at the outset that the universe has no meaning, that there is no God or any other kind of creating or superintending power. The meaning we find in our lives we put there ourselves. And this polemic against religion and any form of meaningful universe is not confined to the opening ideological chapters, but is shot through the book. Moreover, he takes it for granted that "people today" can't believe that old religion. He cites Muslims from the Gulf States as the kind of people he has met who come from cultures where traditional faith still seems plausible.
I had the feeling at the World Congress of Positive Psychology, where Csikszentmihalyi was honored along with the other Founding Fathers of the movement, that his position was somewhat outside or askew the main stream of positivity. I now have a better sense of why.
"Flow" is what we feel when we are having what he calls an optimal experience. He describes these as “when a person’s body or mind is stretched to its limits in a voluntary effort to accomplish something difficult and worthwhile.” The flow channel is an optimal path between anxiety and boredom, where your skills and your challenges meet. The result of experiencing flow is that your own consciousness becomes more complex.
Most of Csikszentmihalyi's examples come from avocations - music, art, athletics, crafts. He says that we can experience flow in our jobs as well, though most of his examples are drawn from the white collar professions. It was surprising to me that he did not treat marriage or childrearing as common settings for flow - the social relationships at the core of positive psychology. Instead, the social relationships chapter was mostly about friendship.
Most of positive psychology treats religion as the most reliable setting, outside of family life, for positive relations, for serving others and feeling that your life is a meaningful part of a larger whole.
Csikszentmihalyi, on the other hand, pronounces religion false, and worse. He simply declares at the outset that the universe has no meaning, that there is no God or any other kind of creating or superintending power. The meaning we find in our lives we put there ourselves. And this polemic against religion and any form of meaningful universe is not confined to the opening ideological chapters, but is shot through the book. Moreover, he takes it for granted that "people today" can't believe that old religion. He cites Muslims from the Gulf States as the kind of people he has met who come from cultures where traditional faith still seems plausible.
I had the feeling at the World Congress of Positive Psychology, where Csikszentmihalyi was honored along with the other Founding Fathers of the movement, that his position was somewhat outside or askew the main stream of positivity. I now have a better sense of why.
Friday, September 30, 2011
Twice as Many Morning People as Night Owls (so ha!)
Cornell sociologists Scott Golder and Michael Macy studied the moods that people express in their Twitter messages. They found a pattern through the day - happy in the morning, trough in the later afternoon, picking up again last thing. Likewise, happy tweets were more likely on the weekend than Monday (or the equivalent in other cultures).
One side finding that I, a morning person, found particularly interesting was this one:
One side finding that I, a morning person, found particularly interesting was this one:
The pair found that about 7 percent of the users qualified as “night owls,” showing peaks in upbeat-sounding messages around midnight and beyond, and about 16 percent were morning people, who showed such peaks very early in the day.
Thursday, September 29, 2011
Gratitude vs. Social Closure
One of the best practical tools of positive psychology is the gratitude notebook. In it you write, say, three things a day that you are grateful for. This helps you feel grateful in general, as a daily attitude, and cuts down on complaining and self-pity.
Gretchen Rubin, in her Happiness Project, found that she was more grateful if she compared down than if she compared up. That is, if she started thinking "I'm grateful I'm not ..." rather than "I wish I were ...," she ended up more grateful.
Social closure works like that, too, but in a negative way. Social closure is an idea developed by Max Weber to explain how status differences get turned into hard divisions between groups. The higher status group picks some small and mostly arbitrary difference between itself and the group immediately below, and tries to close ranks on the basis of that distinction. Educational credentials are the most important tools for status difference today, but practically any difference can be pressed into this service. And the group below, facing exclusion, resists being excluded. But they, in turn, tend to close against the group below them, engendering the same kind of resistance, and so on to the bottom of the social structure.
We can feel grateful that we do not have the problems of those worse off than us, without thereby wishing to exclude them from our society.
The fruit of social closure is a status ladder. The fruit of gratitude is compassion.
Gretchen Rubin, in her Happiness Project, found that she was more grateful if she compared down than if she compared up. That is, if she started thinking "I'm grateful I'm not ..." rather than "I wish I were ...," she ended up more grateful.
Social closure works like that, too, but in a negative way. Social closure is an idea developed by Max Weber to explain how status differences get turned into hard divisions between groups. The higher status group picks some small and mostly arbitrary difference between itself and the group immediately below, and tries to close ranks on the basis of that distinction. Educational credentials are the most important tools for status difference today, but practically any difference can be pressed into this service. And the group below, facing exclusion, resists being excluded. But they, in turn, tend to close against the group below them, engendering the same kind of resistance, and so on to the bottom of the social structure.
We can feel grateful that we do not have the problems of those worse off than us, without thereby wishing to exclude them from our society.
The fruit of social closure is a status ladder. The fruit of gratitude is compassion.
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
NSF Helps Science Moms Have Their Grants and Babies, Too
The National Science Foundation has announced new policies to accommodate women scientists get and keep big science grants while having and raising children.
These changes are in response to a sociological study by Elaine Eklund that women scientists are twice as likely as their male counterparts to regret not having more children. Moreover, the science policy makers are worried by evidence that young women are diverting themselves from science careers because of the difficulties they see in combining that work with a family.
This is excellent news. I have blogged before about how the family-unfriendliness of science was scaring women off. I see these new policies as evidence that the tide is turning.
These changes are in response to a sociological study by Elaine Eklund that women scientists are twice as likely as their male counterparts to regret not having more children. Moreover, the science policy makers are worried by evidence that young women are diverting themselves from science careers because of the difficulties they see in combining that work with a family.
This is excellent news. I have blogged before about how the family-unfriendliness of science was scaring women off. I see these new policies as evidence that the tide is turning.
Tuesday, September 27, 2011
Do What You Really Find Fun, Not What You Wish You Found Fun
Gretchen Rubin's Happiness Project revealed a truth to her that she found very helpful, but also sad: she often did things that she did not enjoy because she thought she should enjoy them. She concludes
I, on the other hand, have a long "Thank you, Lord" list of things that other people enjoy, which I am grateful not to desire. The list began with "Thank you, Lord, I do not want a boat." New items get added all the time. Contentment with what you have, and counting what you do not desire, is the cheapest way to feel rich - and in that way, I am loaded.
Accepting my true likes and dislikes bring me a kind of sadness. … First, it makes me sad to realize my limitations. The world offers so much! – so much beauty, so much fun, and I am unable to appreciate most of it. But it also makes me sad because, in many ways, I wish I were different.I think Gretchen Rubin is a more adventuresome person than I am. She is sad that she doesn't enjoy many things that other people do. Rubin's list of what she wishes she enjoyed seems to be higher status culture items - classical music, vs. pop - rather than higher cost items. I think her desire to appreciate beauty is honorable. And realizing that some kinds of beauty just do not give her pleasure is an important kind of honesty.
I, on the other hand, have a long "Thank you, Lord" list of things that other people enjoy, which I am grateful not to desire. The list began with "Thank you, Lord, I do not want a boat." New items get added all the time. Contentment with what you have, and counting what you do not desire, is the cheapest way to feel rich - and in that way, I am loaded.
Saturday, September 24, 2011
Most Republicans Think Human Beings Were Created Less Than 10,000 Years Ago

Jay Livingstone, at Sociological Images, has made this fine (though sad) graph based on Gallup data. The three options Gallup offered are:
God created human beings in their present form within the last ten thousand years;
Humans evolved, God had no part in the process; or
Humans evolved, God guided the process.
Friday, September 23, 2011
What "Happy Wife, Happy Life" Means - for the Wife
Gretchen Rubin, in The Happiness Project, has an interesting take on the proverb "If mama ain't happy, ain't nobody happy" - or its pithier version, "Happy wife, happy life."
Rubin is herself a wife and mother. She believes that this proverb is true (with which I agree). She also argues that because it is true, she has a responsibility to her family to try to be happy. As a result of her happiness project, she made a concerted effort to be less critical when things didn't go as she hoped with her husband and children, and to enjoy more what her family did with and for her.
Rubin says her effort to be pleased paid off for her family as well as for herself.
Rubin is herself a wife and mother. She believes that this proverb is true (with which I agree). She also argues that because it is true, she has a responsibility to her family to try to be happy. As a result of her happiness project, she made a concerted effort to be less critical when things didn't go as she hoped with her husband and children, and to enjoy more what her family did with and for her.
Rubin says her effort to be pleased paid off for her family as well as for herself.
Thursday, September 22, 2011
Want Secure Kids? Hug Them When They are Small
Fascinating new research shows that holding and caring for children when they are little turns on genes that reduce the child's stress responses, and helps them grow up balanced and resilient.
We are wonderfully made that an activity that feels so good to grownups is also of such lasting benefit to children.
We are wonderfully made that an activity that feels so good to grownups is also of such lasting benefit to children.
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Erotic Capital is Right on the Main Point
Catherine Hakim's new book, Erotic Capital, makes an interesting case that beauty, charm, and sexiness are an important personal asset - right up there with money, education, and connections.
She further argues that erotic capital is the great asset that women have more of than men. She thinks this is so in part because women work more at developing their attractive assets. Mostly, though, women's advantage comes from the fact that, on the whole, men desire sex more than women do.
Hakim cites studies showing that beauty confers an advantage in pay of 10 - 20% across industries. This is comparable to the pay advantage that comes from being taller.
Hakim thinks that an unholy alliance of patriarchy and radical feminism has suppressed the idea that erotic capital is powerful and is just as honorable as any other kind of capital.
The book, as a whole, is disappointingly thin in its empirical support. Nonetheless, I think the basic idea is true and worth developing.
She further argues that erotic capital is the great asset that women have more of than men. She thinks this is so in part because women work more at developing their attractive assets. Mostly, though, women's advantage comes from the fact that, on the whole, men desire sex more than women do.
Hakim cites studies showing that beauty confers an advantage in pay of 10 - 20% across industries. This is comparable to the pay advantage that comes from being taller.
Hakim thinks that an unholy alliance of patriarchy and radical feminism has suppressed the idea that erotic capital is powerful and is just as honorable as any other kind of capital.
The book, as a whole, is disappointingly thin in its empirical support. Nonetheless, I think the basic idea is true and worth developing.
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
Don't Ask, Don't Tell, a Centrist Policy, Reaches Its Timely End
When Bill Clinton was first elected president, one of the first items he tried to spend his political capital on was repealing the ban on gays and lesbians serving in the military. However, the opposition from conservatives was so strong that he had to compromise. The result was Don't Ask, Don't Tell.
Don't Ask, Don't Tell was a centrist policy at the time. It ended the earlier policy of actively ferreting out homosexuals in the military as a security threat. This was a liberal gain. But it stopped short of fully accepting homosexuality. This was a conservative gain.
In the years that followed, the sentiments of the country changed. Young people, in particular, accept gays and lesbians as normal Americans. This is true even of young people who are otherwise quite conservative. Just as important, a generation of military leaders came to power who also accepted gays and lesbians as normal members of the military. Their testimony, it seems, was the crucial step in convincing some Congressional Republicans to vote with the Democrats to repeal the law underlying Don't Ask, Don't Tell.
This story is the right way to make a controversial social change: take centrist steps until the change is no longer controversial to most people. Some people think this change should have been made long ago, that Don't Ask, Don't Tell was a sellout. Others think the change should not have been made at all, that homosexuality should not be normalized. But this day, when the Don't Ask, Don't Tell policy officially ended in the U.S. military, policy caught up with majority sentiment. Which is a good day for centrist social change.
Don't Ask, Don't Tell was a centrist policy at the time. It ended the earlier policy of actively ferreting out homosexuals in the military as a security threat. This was a liberal gain. But it stopped short of fully accepting homosexuality. This was a conservative gain.
In the years that followed, the sentiments of the country changed. Young people, in particular, accept gays and lesbians as normal Americans. This is true even of young people who are otherwise quite conservative. Just as important, a generation of military leaders came to power who also accepted gays and lesbians as normal members of the military. Their testimony, it seems, was the crucial step in convincing some Congressional Republicans to vote with the Democrats to repeal the law underlying Don't Ask, Don't Tell.
This story is the right way to make a controversial social change: take centrist steps until the change is no longer controversial to most people. Some people think this change should have been made long ago, that Don't Ask, Don't Tell was a sellout. Others think the change should not have been made at all, that homosexuality should not be normalized. But this day, when the Don't Ask, Don't Tell policy officially ended in the U.S. military, policy caught up with majority sentiment. Which is a good day for centrist social change.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Gigi Grazer's Anti-Divorce Gem
NOTE: The following is anti-divorce. Proceed forewarned.
Gigi Levangie Grazer is an expert on divorce, the hard way. The twice-divorced author of The Starter Wife and the screenplay of Stepmom has a fine piece of hard-won wisdom in the Huffington Post. I can't write with this kind of authority.
My favorite nugget is this:
Gigi Levangie Grazer is an expert on divorce, the hard way. The twice-divorced author of The Starter Wife and the screenplay of Stepmom has a fine piece of hard-won wisdom in the Huffington Post. I can't write with this kind of authority.
My favorite nugget is this:
When you do go out with someone (after the kids go to bed), you size them up not only against your standards, but the standards of your children. You're not the only one going out on that date -- your seven-year-old is right there with you, with his toothy grin. Your fourteen-year-old is scowling in the background. Your stoic ten-year-old has tears welling up in his eyes.
Frankly, other than superficial dating far away from your kids' eyes and ears, E.S.P. might be the only thing that makes sense for the single parent.
Sunday, September 18, 2011
Our Moderately Progressive Tax Rate
For my conservative friends who have been telling me that the poorer half of Americans pay no taxes:
According to Citizens for Tax Justice, the lowest 20 percent of income earners (those with an average cash income of 12,500 a year) are paying about 16.2 percent of their income in taxes. The next 20 percent (those with an average cash income of 25,300 a year) are paying 20.7 percent of their income in taxes. The top 1 percent (with an average cash income of 1,254,000) are paying more but still just 30 percent of their total income. But if you go a step above that and calculate the tax rate for the 400 richest Americans in 2008, you find that they only paid 18.1 percent of their income in taxes. That is less than those making an average of 25,300 a year.
Saturday, September 17, 2011
Fog Happiness
Gretchen Rubin takes up an important finding in happiness research: when a couple has children, their marital happiness goes down. After pondering this finding compared to her own experience, and compared with the obvious fact that most parents are happy that they have children, she came to this conclusion:
She calls this “fog happiness.” Caring for children, especially small children, may be a trial at any given moment. Yet the experience of being a parent, having children, of family in the round, is deeply satisfying to most people.
I think that the kind of well-being that comes from having children is the single clearest path from "happiness" to "meaningfulness." And thinking about why raising children produces fog happiness is an instance of what Aristotle means when he says that contemplation is the highest happiness.
I have to reject the experts’ argument that children don’t bring happiness. Because they do. Not always in a moment-to-moment way, perhaps, but in a more profound way.
She calls this “fog happiness.” Caring for children, especially small children, may be a trial at any given moment. Yet the experience of being a parent, having children, of family in the round, is deeply satisfying to most people.
I think that the kind of well-being that comes from having children is the single clearest path from "happiness" to "meaningfulness." And thinking about why raising children produces fog happiness is an instance of what Aristotle means when he says that contemplation is the highest happiness.
Friday, September 16, 2011
Gretchen Rubin's First Splendid Truth about Happiness
Gretchen Rubin develops several Splendid Truths in the course of her Happiness Project. The
First Splendid Truth is
“To be happy, I need to think about feeling good, feeling bad, and feeling right, in an atmosphere of growth.”
This is a dense statement. We need to think about feeling good and think about feeling bad because one of the unexpected findings of happiness research is that feeling happy and feeling unhappy are separate feelings. She found over the course of her project that reducing the actions that made her feel unhappy gave the single biggest boost to her happiness; however, they did so more by removing an obstacle than by automatically creating happy feelings.
"Feeling right" is about living, giving, and working in a way that feels good and meaningful. I think living meaningfully is the hardest part of achieving deep and lasting happiness. I believe that the difference that Rubin found between feeling happy and feeling right is the same distinction that Aristotle was getting at when he said happiness is an action in accordance with virtue, but really the deepest happiness (which not all will achieve) comes from contemplation.
The idea that she had to think about these feelings in an atmosphere of growth adds a necessary dynamic element to living happily. It also raises what I think is an interesting gender difference in thinking about what makes us happy. Martin Seligman, the guru of positive psychology, recently revised his long-standing definition of what makes for a happy life to add an element of achievement. It strikes me that growth and achievement are characteristically feminine and masculine ways of thinking about the same dynamic process.
I think Gretchen Rubin's First Splendid Truth about happiness holds up, and makes sense within the larger philosophical and empirical study of happiness.
This is a dense statement. We need to think about feeling good and think about feeling bad because one of the unexpected findings of happiness research is that feeling happy and feeling unhappy are separate feelings. She found over the course of her project that reducing the actions that made her feel unhappy gave the single biggest boost to her happiness; however, they did so more by removing an obstacle than by automatically creating happy feelings.
"Feeling right" is about living, giving, and working in a way that feels good and meaningful. I think living meaningfully is the hardest part of achieving deep and lasting happiness. I believe that the difference that Rubin found between feeling happy and feeling right is the same distinction that Aristotle was getting at when he said happiness is an action in accordance with virtue, but really the deepest happiness (which not all will achieve) comes from contemplation.
The idea that she had to think about these feelings in an atmosphere of growth adds a necessary dynamic element to living happily. It also raises what I think is an interesting gender difference in thinking about what makes us happy. Martin Seligman, the guru of positive psychology, recently revised his long-standing definition of what makes for a happy life to add an element of achievement. It strikes me that growth and achievement are characteristically feminine and masculine ways of thinking about the same dynamic process.
I think Gretchen Rubin's First Splendid Truth about happiness holds up, and makes sense within the larger philosophical and empirical study of happiness.
Thursday, September 15, 2011
“Enthusiasm is a form of social courage”
I commend Gretchen Rubin's The Happiness Project. It is very gruntled.
I was particularly taken with this sequence of observations at the end of the book:
“Being critical made me feel more sophisticated and intelligent.”
“Enthusiasm is a form of social courage.”
“A willingness to be pleased requires modesty and even innocence.”
I was particularly taken with this sequence of observations at the end of the book:
“Being critical made me feel more sophisticated and intelligent.”
“Enthusiasm is a form of social courage.”
“A willingness to be pleased requires modesty and even innocence.”
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
The Endpoint of Religious Evolution is Robert Bellah
Robert Bellah's last major work (as he says - he is in his eighties), Religion in Human Evolution, was designed to show that the world religions that emerged in the "axial age" around 500 BCE grew out of parallel social evolution. The new, very hierarchical and often brutal states of that era produced a reaction of "renouncers" - mostly traveling teachers who criticized the current state in the name of a perfect standard located in the past or in another plane beyond this one. This is an interesting story. The sociology seems very plausible to me. I was a little disappointed that there doesn't seem to be much religion left in his discussion of religion once he has extracted the philosophy he was looking for, but that might be a story for someone else to develop.
Bellah then tries to tie this moment of social and intellectual evolution to the larger framework of biological evolution. The link between them is that playing, which animals and early humans did, led to singing and dancing and rituals. The rituals, which still partly endure, became the basis of religion and of social solidarity - a very Durkheimian thought. The evolutionary connection between play and ritual is, he admits, a late addition to the book. In fact, he barely mentions play through the whole core, where he compares the various axial age proto-philosophers. Still, I can see how this might be true. Worth someone investigating.
Then Bellah starts going off the rails. He says that just because the world religions evolved from earlier tribal religions, and from animal play, doesn't mean they are better or true. He wants to avoid judging any religious metanarrative from the perspective of another religious metanarrative. So instead he judges them from the metanarrative of evolution, on the grounds that evolution is the only metanarrative believed by nearly all thinking people.
And then I think he gets himself into a real tangle. On the one hand, he says that there is no standard, not even evolution, from which to choose among the religions. On the other hand, he extracts from all of them an "axial ethic" of universal equality. Moreover, he says that that the axial thinkers were utopians, but it would be unreasonable to try to make more than modest social reforms based on their ideas. And while it would be improper for this book, which ends its story 2000 years ago, to comment on the subsequent evolution of religion, he does think “it is imperative that humans wake up to what is happening [to the environment] and take the necessary dramatic steps that are so clearly needed but also at present so clearly ignored by the powers of this earth.” He doesn't specify what those steps are, but the main culprit he names is the invention of agriculture.
Bellah's position, that the point of all the world's religions is universal equality in social ethics, and environmentalism is a quasi-religious imperative, sounds like just what you would expect a Berkeley sociology professor to believe. The outcome of religion in human evolution from the paleolithic to the axial age is mild reformist liberalism.
Bellah then tries to tie this moment of social and intellectual evolution to the larger framework of biological evolution. The link between them is that playing, which animals and early humans did, led to singing and dancing and rituals. The rituals, which still partly endure, became the basis of religion and of social solidarity - a very Durkheimian thought. The evolutionary connection between play and ritual is, he admits, a late addition to the book. In fact, he barely mentions play through the whole core, where he compares the various axial age proto-philosophers. Still, I can see how this might be true. Worth someone investigating.
Then Bellah starts going off the rails. He says that just because the world religions evolved from earlier tribal religions, and from animal play, doesn't mean they are better or true. He wants to avoid judging any religious metanarrative from the perspective of another religious metanarrative. So instead he judges them from the metanarrative of evolution, on the grounds that evolution is the only metanarrative believed by nearly all thinking people.
And then I think he gets himself into a real tangle. On the one hand, he says that there is no standard, not even evolution, from which to choose among the religions. On the other hand, he extracts from all of them an "axial ethic" of universal equality. Moreover, he says that that the axial thinkers were utopians, but it would be unreasonable to try to make more than modest social reforms based on their ideas. And while it would be improper for this book, which ends its story 2000 years ago, to comment on the subsequent evolution of religion, he does think “it is imperative that humans wake up to what is happening [to the environment] and take the necessary dramatic steps that are so clearly needed but also at present so clearly ignored by the powers of this earth.” He doesn't specify what those steps are, but the main culprit he names is the invention of agriculture.
Bellah's position, that the point of all the world's religions is universal equality in social ethics, and environmentalism is a quasi-religious imperative, sounds like just what you would expect a Berkeley sociology professor to believe. The outcome of religion in human evolution from the paleolithic to the axial age is mild reformist liberalism.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
