Friday, May 24, 2013

Liberal Fairness, Conservative Fairness, and What They Have to Do With Justice

Justice means getting what you deserve.

This is a traditional definition, which I believe is true.

Jonathan Haidt, in The Righteous Mind, notes that "fairness" is a basic moral value, to which we have a strong emotional attachment.  However, Haidt found an interesting ideological difference in what fairness means.

To liberals, fairness means that you get an equal share.
To conservatives, fairness means that you get a share proportionate to what you put in.

However, neither view of fairness is based on getting the share you deserve. 

Knowing what you truly deserve is a very deep and hard question.  Ultimately, I think, only God can know that.  The best human approximation is how parents try to give their children what they should have, what would be most beneficial to their lives and development.  But, as all parents know, this approximation is uncertain, and we are prone to mess it up in practice.

So we use fairness as a rough proxy for justice.  But our different ideological views of what fairness entails has very difference consequences for the kinds of society we are trying to make.


Michael Kruse said...

Well said.

patti hearst... said...

On which side do you fall?

gruntled said...

I am a centrist, looking for justice directly.

Dennis Evans said...

Although I have never been a parent, I think a parent would be wrong to "take sides" and stand with one interpretation. It seems that parenthood, and family in general, requires a balance of equality and reward. Should society be any different?

patti hearst... said...


gruntled said...

Not through the proxy of either equality or proportionality.

patti hearst... said...

Through what precisely then?

gruntled said...

God knows what we deserve by knowing us (and everything else). Parents try to judge what their children deserve by knowing each child intimately, and by desiring the good for each child. This is hard enough with children, and gets harder the further we move from that level of intimate knowledge and concern. But that is, I think, the right standard for seeking justice.