Friday, September 07, 2007

MADD Logic: Ban Teen Driving

I support Choose Responsibility, a national effort to create a drinking license for 18 to 20 year olds. I live among college students. About a third of them don't drink alcohol at all, which I applaud. The majority, though, begin drinking underage. The rule we have set for ourselves today is that we adults forbid ourselves to teach students anything about responsible drinking before we turn them loose at 21. The result is a serious problem with binge drinking and regular drunkenness even among students who we know are smart and teachable. I think it would be better to try to teach young people how one can drink responsibly.

The main opponent of Choose Responsibility is Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD). Like all sensible people, I am against drunk driving. I feel safe in saying that all Choose Responsibility signatories are against drunk driving. What we differ on is which method will best reduce drunk driving (by anyone), and which method will best reduce teen drunkenness. I think the current method, formally forbidding teen drinking, has proven ineffective on both counts.

One of the arguments that MADD makes is that the mandatory 21 drinking age has saved 17 thousand teenagers who, statistically, would otherwise have died in drunk driving accidents. This is probably true. You know how we could save even more lives? Forbid teen driving altogether. Teenagers are much more dangerous drivers than adults are, especially teen boys. We could save many lives by forbidding them from driving. Is anyone ready for that national experiment? I'm not.

Yes, teen drinking is dangerous, more dangerous than drinking by adults is. But teen anything is more dangerous than the adult practice of the same thing, because teens take bigger risks and have less judgment about what is risky. In every other sphere we try to combat teen risk taking through education. I believe we should do the same with drinking.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I have literally the exact same thoughts on the matter, and have actually used the exact same analogy in debate. Well written, and an excellent point that needs to be addressed.

MissWrite said...

Every parent of a teenager knows what worry the phrase 'Can I borrow the car keys?' brings. You worry the entire time from the moment the car leaves the drive to the moment it arrives back safe and sound. Then you can relax—until the next time.

Well now you can end the worries. With a simple little device that is easily attached under the dashboard of the car you can know where your teen was during their travels, and get a complete overview of their driving habits as well. That way you can always be sure they are driving safely.

The Car Checkup device is a palm-sized gadget that attaches to your 1996 or newer model car under the dash and not only will give your car a complete checkup as you drive, but track your route, and the driving patterns of the operator as well. Know if your teen is abusing the breaks with hard stops, or overly fast acceleration. These things are not only had on an automobile, but create unsafe driving conditions as well.

Keeping tabs on your teen is vital for their safety. You'll always know they are being safe and responsible when operating the car, and they'll know you care enough to be sure they do. Check out the car checkup at http://www.carcheckup.com today and find out how this simple little tool can give you back your peace of mind.